returncatalogbottom
rules1. you must be 18+ to use this site 2. no NSFW/gore 3. no bigotry or slurs 4. if staff don't like your post they may delete it or ban you

anon
>>196252
were not making them youre issues were solving our own issues internally and u all are veing weird about it :/
>>196256
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196252
I think its more the other countries who get made when we keep our heritage part of our identity, which is a you problem xD
>>196257
SadChan🍉🍉
Like if I say oh Im Italian, and ESL italian person will be like UHHHH NO YOUR NOT which tbh is literally them
1. not understanding what heritage means to americans and
2. literally not understanding what 'being italian' beans in American English
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196253
if your solution implies us then yeah i mean we're on our right as citizens of our nations
>>196259
anon
xd*
anon
>>196256
i mean yea you can squak about it but we are gonna think ur annoying for doing so just to be honest
>>196260
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196259
the thing is that you can do that all you want and you can think about me the way you want but the general consensus in Chile at least is that you're just an american larping as a chilean (in this example at least)
>>196263
KimNix
you know what the difference between america and a cup of yogurt is? the cup of yogurt will actually form a culture after 250years of being left out
anon
im not arguing that :p
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196260
im curious, do u consider a chinese person in chile just chilean? or do you call them chinese.
>>196265>>196264
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196263
it depends on how familiar they are with the culture and language. i literally couldn't care less if their parents were born in Chongqing and Wuhan and never spoke a single word of Spanish, but if their son grows up here and assimilates the culture and in general behaves just like the next guy then yeah he's chilean even if he somehow isn't legally chilean
>>196269
anon
>>196263
this is the core of the issue no other country has immigration like we do. like a huge fraction of our population has personally met the family member who brought the family over to america
>>196266
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196265
>>196265
>no other country has immigration like we do.
this 100%. no other country really understands what its like to have a different culture in EVERY household on the block.
anon
like u dont understand the need until u walk around a big city and realize like 50% of ppl are ESL and practice very different religion and customs at home and there's neighborhoods for each specific place ppl come from
>>196276
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196264
yea thats fair, just wondering... i think its also important to remmebr we are just talking about like... other people.

We are nice here no one is attacccc anyone else :)
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
because like, in places like South America, ethnicity means shit. my grandma has a french last name, my mom has a mapuche last name, blablabla. yet i just consider myself chilean because i just have nothing in common both with mapuche and french ppl
anon
Like theres majority ethiopian and somali neighborhoods near me and they would be offended if u mixed up the two because their cultures are no the same. u gotta be aware and be able to understand these differences. annoying some random person across the oceans is the least of our worries in navigating these situations
>>196276>>196272
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196271
100% if you mix up wethere someone is puerto rican or dominican in NYC fr watch the fuck out ahahaha
>>196274
SadChan🍉🍉
Yea it was very productive hearing ur side of it Nadia
anon
so its weird to be like "dont call urself dominican ur not literally living in dominica" thats not how america works. are we supposed to invent whole new words for every single culture or ethnicity just to avoid stepping on some internet toes? its confusing enough as it is.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196268
>>196271
i guess i would be ok with a guy that's never been in Chile claiming to be chilean if he somehow proved to be in touch with our country in one way or another. like
>>196277>>196278
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196276
Nah, its okay. Like, its just an American thing that I don't think a foreigner can really understand until you come here.
>>196279
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196276
idk, speaking spanish, liking our food, acting like we do in general
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
because like, again, ethnicity in Latin America in general is just something we don't care because this part of the world is just a lot of mixed races
>>196281
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196280
well america had this whole thing called chattle slavery and the civil rights movement and we care A LOT about ethnicity now xD
>>196284
SadChan🍉🍉
like, either celebrating diversity and being as welcoming as possible or jsut the racistrs lol
anon
And "well stop caring abt ethnicity then" is like the opposite of a solution unfortunately. the wounds have yet to heal, ignoring them just makes things worse and in fact its usually the most racist and segregatory arguing for those points
>>196286
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196281
yeah we know because from our point of view yall just reinvented the chaste system to some extent
>>196285
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196284
its not really like that. well it is in the case of specifically black americans because their communities are devestated by racist redlining and the follow on economic effects of slavery.

but in general heritage is something that is celebrated. people keep a deep personal connection to their home countries even if its superficial. you arent going to logic away our deep cultural ties to the hundreds of homelands we all originate from.

its just not something someone who isnt american can understand I think.

that said I 100% understand hating american posers who come to chilean being like "im chilean" and barely speaking the language and doing things that are socially awkward because they dont know the culture and stuff
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196283
i'm not saying y'all should stop caring, but that's something we actually can do because we don't have to be responsibles of century and a half of slavery. in Chile everyone was able to vote regardless of their ethnicity around 1870
>>196287
i personally don't get mad, i just can't take them serious
>>196287>>196289
anon
>>196286
i mean yeah, we cant stop caring because of what i described, so how to keep caring (important) while not "claiming to be other nationalities"? how to recognize and reconcile these differences without using the words of r country of origin? i think it's silly to get mad at this
>>196286
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i mean i try to understand but...
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196286
I mean didnt all the super brutal spanish plantation owners / genociders basically just interbreed with the natives to the point that you cant tell them apart anymore
>>196291
anon
>that said I 100% understand hating american posers who come to chilean being like "im chilean" and barely speaking the language and doing things that are socially awkward because they dont know the culture and stuff
very much agree this is like an inter-american issue its kind of trite/douchy to go and larp as that country in that country, for italians or chileans or irish alike, this is pretty well understood among americans
>>196488
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196289
nope.. but kinda? like i don't wanna sound like an ass but apparently our genociders were better than yours in that regard
>>196294
shrimp
im chilean
anon
its the whole toupee falicy thing. ppl think american tourists are loud and obnoxious because you notice the loud obnoxious ones and not the majority who are calm and normal
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196291
well they killed way more people I think idk. ive learned a lot about colonialism and I genuinely would think that spanish colonialism was hte most brutal of all the colonial empires except maybe belgium. belgium was crazy.
>>196296
anon
diego de landa moment
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196294
spanish colonialism wasn't the most brutal empire, it was just the one who expanded the most. like there was a period of time in which sunsets weren't a thing in the Spanish Empire because they always had a colony somewhere in the world
SadChan🍉🍉
I think if you made a Evil Colonialism teir list Spain is number 1 - S rank
anon
i think we're getting into like hitler vs moussolini territory. yes theres probably a definitive answer but it does no good to figure it out and it hurts a lot of feelings along the way
>>196302
SadChan🍉🍉
the population of indiginous peoples in south america is estimate to have declined by 90-95% by the 17th century. :O
>>196300
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196299
yeah but that's very hard to calculate and it's not like they actively murdered 95% of the habitants of the continent. they brought viruses and stuff, but even during the period of colonization there were huge debates on how indigenous people should be treated. the most known one is Bartolomé de Las Casas
>>196303
anon
everyones gor their unique ways to deal with the echos of imperial colonialism and americans is doing the whole heritage thing. and its a lot better for us than any other solution thats been proposed
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196298
yea I was thinking this as I was looking it up like. I am genuinely interested by the natives were cut by 95% in both north and south america pretty much.
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196300
yea thats america too tbh. but ive read accounts of the brutality of the plantation owners and its pretty sickening. its the same shit as happened in america but 200 years earlier and people just kind of get more violent and horrible the farther back in time u go.
SadChan🍉🍉
the only thing that changes is the scale of destruction imo, idk maybe thats really ignorant
SadChan🍉🍉
like genghis khan killed millions of people in a single week when he burned samarkhand to the ground that doesnt really compare to WWII where its like, a years long grind where there was at least an Attempt (TM) to treat POWs and captured civilians.

the empires of ages passed would have just executed everybody.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i mean while i agree the Spanish Crown wasn't particularly fond of indigenous people (because the debate at the end of the day was "do these people have soul?") i don't think it was more brutal than what happened in the US
>>196307
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196306
I just wrote a paper about how Europeans genuinely had to construct a narrative of MORAL superiority over indiginous peoples to justify their genocide and colonialism.
SadChan🍉🍉
the average european genuinely thought natives were lucky and should be grateful to labor for htem
SadChan🍉🍉
ofc there were lots of people who pushed back against that
SadChan🍉🍉
Like the tempest is allegorically a critique on europeans need to be morally superior to the stupid gross native person
SadChan🍉🍉
thats why all the way up until the 1900s europeans and americans were still drawing black people as like evil rapey big lipped demons and such
SadChan🍉🍉
you have to create an entire cultural narrative about how bad this group is so you dont feel bad when you do the most evil shit imaginable to them.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
yeah well.. that didn't happen here. ever
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
because unlike british empire the spaniards were at least kinda interested on the indigenous population. in their own distorted way
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
that's why nowadays while we lost several, probably important, examples of literature like the aztec codex, they rescued some like Popol Vuh which later was used as an argument to protect or at least treat indigenous population in a more human way
shrimp
im pretty sure the spanish did the exact same thing
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
because spaniards saw it as an example of a different civilization aware of how god acts, in their own distorted way
>>196320
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
they also cultured people that not even that later became important, like Felipe Guamán Poma de Ayala, a chronicler that wrote probably one of the most important books of that century
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
like despite how crazy it sound, i don't think Spain was an actually genocidal empire. it segregated people by creating their own chaste system and stuff, lots of people died, but they didn't provoke an intended genocide
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196317
is that like Las Casas and how he petitioned the spanish king to limit the landowners to enslave natives?
SadChan🍉🍉
I really disagree but maybe we just learn different things in different countries. Ive read a few papers about spanish colonialism and it really seems like that doesnt happen until after centuries of genocide and exploitation and then there was a redefining of mixed native identities later
SadChan🍉🍉
like the text Democrates alter, sive de iustis belli causis apud Indos is specifically calling all natives sodomites and rapists as justification for the landowners laws and why the New Laws of Las Casas were rejected by the king (also there was a sort of civil war when the crown tried to enforce it own the landowners)
>>196323
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196322
i think that while reading Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda nowadays is crazy because he has a very aggressive way to describe the situation, even in his own narrative it's important to acknowledge that we wasn't proposing a genocide at all. the whole point of that book is that Juan thinks they need to be converted to christianism to reach salvation, and also to become civilized. he thought it was something that had to be done by any means necessary, but that like, the point, he didn't see it as a genocide but as a war against an exisisting evil in a "culture" that didn't know about god
>>196325
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196323
not sure if its a language miscommunic ation but we do consider that genocide in europe. the destruction of religion, language, cultural identity. the indios schools
>>196326
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196325
yeah but Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda died like, almost a century before manuscripts like Popol Vuh were saved and some books writen by "culturized indians" were published. like at the end of the day there wasn't a genocide if you consider all those things necessary. it did happen in countries like Argentina with the Selk'nams, which were literally hunted to extinction. but Spain while having questionable methods didn't rule a genocide
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
they were evil, mistreated the indigenous population, gave them illnesses they never met and people from those ages compared the situation to the plagues from the Bible but, like, despite everything it's hard to call it genocide. it was colonialism at its fullest but not genocide, they needed a group to exploit
SadChan🍉🍉
i think it depends on ur definition of genocide but the brutal forced conversion to catholicism would be considered genocide today, and also it was an apartheid state because european spandiards had more rights in their legal system than latam born spaniards, evne if they had no native blood.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i think calling it an apartheid state is a bit ethnocentrist
>>196330
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196329
yea maybe, I guess its more a caste system?
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
it was a caste system yeah
SadChan🍉🍉
what does apartheid get defined as?
SadChan🍉🍉
#ai define what an apartheid country is

an apartheid country is one where a dominant racial or ethnic group enforces systemic segregation and discrimination against other groups through laws and policies, denying them basic rights, political representation, and economic opportunities. historically, south africa's regime was the most notorious example, but the term might be used for any state maintaining similar oppressive structures.
define what an apartheid country is
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
yeah but it was a caste system, not an apartheid
shrimp
#ai is a caste system an apartheid

a caste system and apartheid share similarities in enforcing social hierarchies, but they're not the same. apartheid was a legally codified racial segregation system, mostly in south africa. caste systems, like in india, are deeply embedded cultural and religious hierarchies, sometimes reinforced by law but mostly by tradition. both are oppressive, just with different structures.
is a caste system an apartheid
>>196336
SadChan🍉🍉
yeh i see i see
SadChan🍉🍉
There were definitely big differences in how the british and french colonized north america and the spanish colonized south america i have some interesting papers pulled up. i think colonialism is just bad.

the spanish def did the same shit as the british and french though and created narratives of native barbarism and ugliness. that they were all godless rapey nasty creatures who deserve slvaery for being so horrible. they jsut responded in different ways.
>>196340
SadChan🍉🍉
I know in modern mexico that native peopels still have a huge problem with accessing political representation and the government almost never builds infrastructure in native areas because they just dont have any power in government so they are super disenfranchised in that country to this day. and its also an example of how there was cultural genocide, like how dia de los muertes and all saints day are aztec holidays that they created to convert the people to catholicism, they built churches on top of the aztec holy sites and temples that people would make pilgrimages too.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196338
i really don't think it's the same because i don't remember a single ethnic group that was brought to extinction because of the spanish crown while i know at least one that got extinct because of the british... and that's just a group that got literally mass murdered because there are plenty of languages and cosmogonies that got completely extincted in the US because of the brits
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i literally can't remember a single example of a civilization that suffered the same fate with the spaniards, not in south america at least
>>196355
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
like i know the selk'nam, but the argentinean government was responsible of that like 150 years ago
SadChan🍉🍉
yea but that wasnt spain tho
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
yeah that was argentina
SadChan🍉🍉
I would just heavily caution revisionist history that paints your country in a more favorable light. The death toll was so incredibly massive and the spread of disease so powerful there is no way there werent entire cultures that were wiped out. There are people in america who distort history to make the genocide of natives in north america 'not that bad'.
>>196346>>196548
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196345
nah i have a position that's way different than what they teach in school. i have more arguments to say the Spaniards led to a genocide than to say they didn't. the thing is i still kinda can't fully dig it??? its weird ik but i don't wanna assume
>>196348
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196346
I kind of get it too. like for me I think there is an incentive to not believe my country and history are completely evil and there were lots of good things america did too.
SadChan🍉🍉
I think americans, well left leaning americans, are extremely motivated to examine the horrors of the past and call colonialism out for what it is.
SadChan🍉🍉
I also something that gets lost in history is all the people who spoke out against the genocides, slavery and such. Like people knew in 1500 that this shit was insanely evil and did it anyway. There was no "people just had different values then". Many people, especially relgious people, spoke out against slavery and genocide at the time. Abolitionism in america goes back to the very first years of the country in the 1700s. And those voices often get lost to history.
>>196351
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196350
i don't think they knew it was evil. i legit think they were doing their best. people do awful shit with good intentions, everytime
>>196352
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196351
no way. no way they didnt know. if they "thought they were doing their best" then they are literal animals who deserve total death.
>>196569
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
well, they're dead now, it's been half a millennium
SadChan🍉🍉
There was a video I watched on liveleak that haunts me to this day of a bunch of guys in mexico city setting fire to a a chihuahua and laughing and cheering while it burns to deaht. its screams were horrible. it screamed for almost a minute and a half before it stopped moving. it was one of the most unambiguously evil things ive ever seen in my life.

people are evil. people are good. there are evil people in the world. I dont make excuses for evil anymore.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196355
all of these cultures are well known from their cosmogony to their languages
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
matter of fact i know one (1) example of a civilization that might have disappeared because of colonialism

[Wikipedia]
>>196361
SadChan🍉🍉
maya are extinct but their genes still exist in yucatan and oxaxaxaxaaxa
SadChan🍉🍉
maya were pretty much extinct by the aztec tho
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
oh no. the diaguitas are still alive and the calchaqui tribe was conquered by incas
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196357
I learned about them. they predate the incas by hundreds of years and had a unique pottery and tool culture in like 200AD or smth
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
huh
anon
but i thinj its pretty inarguable that they genocided those peoples right
>>196366
SadChan🍉🍉
I think they were mostly extinct by the time the incas rose to power before the spanish arrived
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196364
i mean, how do you define "getting genocided"
SadChan🍉🍉
enslavement, wanton killing, destruction of the language and cultlure, banning of the religion, forced conversion, indian schools, mass forced remigration
anon
destorying their culture and language and people on the basis of said culture/language/people
>>196369
anon
you are running defense for a very weird group of people nadie :/
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196369
then the north american natives didnt get genocided because we still have all their languages and culture preserved today...
>>196373
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196371
no because there are groups that got extinct like the yuki tribe
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196372
it was older than the incas, it might not really have even been around except for one or two villages by the time of the spaniards, but I also think that there are probalby dozens of culutures that were completely exterminatedan d just like america it was only the biggest native nations that survived into the modern era (the sioux, the iriqois, the blackfoot, the mohawk etc as compared ot the aztec, the inca, the maya)
anon
i just think. its weird to go to bat for the spaniards in the 1500s in the americas
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196372
but was spoken by the diaguitas which are still alive and the calchaqui tha, if anything, got coonquered by the incas
anon
they are not a very nice or moral group of people
SadChan🍉🍉
I think its a bit wierd but i dont want 2 press it and make anyone feel badd like nadia said it happend 500 years ago.
anon
im not trying to make u feel bad nadie i just think maybe u should reexamine ur position on this one :/
>>196381
SadChan🍉🍉
I think there might be an element of not wanting to be as bad as the british which is well tbh every country Ive talked to copes like that xD
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196379
i constantly do.
like i said, i think the spanish empire is responsible of mass murder, destroyed very important sources of information of these cultures, tried to ban their religion, tried to convert them to christianity by force and allat
but i don't think genocide is the right word
>>196386>>196588
SadChan🍉🍉
its just wierd to not call it genocidee I think
SadChan🍉🍉
its like if you said "Im 99% sure the holocaust happened"
>>196401
SadChan🍉🍉
why would you say 99%
SadChan🍉🍉
what are you saying by leaving room for doubt lol
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196381
yea I think at that point its just semantics like we all agree the spaniards were evil colonialists.
>>196387
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196386
maybe. i think ethnic cleansing is more accurate tho
oh yeah i agree they're colonialists, i think i said it a long time ago
>>196388
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196387
>thnic cleansing
i dont think people usually make a big distinction between the word genocide and ethnic cleansing like
>>196392
SadChan🍉🍉
there is the UN stages of genocide or w/e
SadChan🍉🍉
it still genocide if you do like what russia did in ukraine in the 1930-80s. ban speaking ukrainian, force the teaching of russian in schools, ban ukrainian cultural expression. you are extirpating the culture to make them russian. its a genocide, and that ban is usually enforced through indiscriminate violence.
SadChan🍉🍉
u can also do a genocide by forced migration, which spain did too. moving tons of spanish indentured workers into these countries to take over and be a higher caste to the natives nad have htem interbreed and stuff and if they get spanish blood in them there is no longer a purely native population. (WHICH IS OBVIOUSLY DIFFERENT FROM JUST NORMAL MIGRATION AND INTERBREEDING BEFORE ANY NAZIS APPEAR AND START TALKING ABOUT WHITE GENOCIDE I SWEAR 2 GOD)
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
like i said before, despite all this, i don't think they were trying to lead them to extinction
SadChan🍉🍉
well, I dont th ink the british or french were either
>>196399
SadChan🍉🍉
Like the british wanted to displace mostly not kill and often employed tribes in their wars and the french even gave citizenship to natives in a lot of their colonies
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196394
i mean, the difference is that the british actually did it regardless of their intentions... like even if we focus in this just "small" tribe, the yuki people, they ended up extinguishing them
>>196403
SadChan🍉🍉
America kind of operates differently where its more like modern isreal where you have an incroaching of homesteaders and slowly pushing hte populations out and putting them in reservations and buildng walls around them
anon
>>196383
agree it's weird vibes to me
anon
i think people doing genocide rarely come out and say "I'm doing a genocide im trying to kill all of you on the basis of your ethnicity" so i think it's weird to require that to make the discussion
>>196405
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196399
you are never going to convince that the spanish didnt eradicate hundreds of small tribes in their conquest of the americas
>>196404
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196403
honestly, i find it hard to believe too. i'd like to investigate a bit more and see if there's at least a single tribe or ethnic group that got extinct during the spanish colonization and if i find it then yeah i would agree they commited genocide
>>196406
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196404
the thing that makes it really difficult was that the spanish expanded MUCH BIGGER AND FASTER than the british and french. the project of spanish colonialism was on a much huger scale than the way british people did it which was mor elike the portuguses feitorias. they british built city states in key areas and traded or farmed around them. the spanish did wholesale cultural replacement. the spanish project was much grander in scale and scope and happened about a hundred years before the british or french really got started in north america. so the spanish didnt really need to distinguish between all these tiny tribes because they are all just targets for extermination/conversion. like the incas themselves ruled over dozens of tribes we no longer know the names of. all we know is the incas and maybe 5 or 6 major cultural groups in this huge area. we dont know those tribes anymore and to the racist spanish they would all just be "Inka" and get thrown onto the hacienda, enslaved and forced to convert to following jesus or get tortured by the inquisition.
>>196418
anon
i just think it's a weird line to draw in the sand like i don't understand the motivation to protect unambiguously evil racist people from a label that calls them evil and racist
>>196408
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196407
because u can call them evil and racist if that's what u wanna do
>>196410
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
but words have meanings
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196410
that's fair but as far as i know i can't say the same
anon
ok well thats concerning to me
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
so?
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i mean what do i do with that info
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
like i don't wanna be a dick here i just think words have meaning and if i wanted to call them evil i'd just do that
anon
integrate it into the collective feedback on your psyche that ghe universe gives you and maybe if 50 other people say the same u will reconsider it? i dunno, what is anyone supposed to do with anything said on the internet. it's all inherently a bit vacuous and inane
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196406
i mean yeah it has to be more difficult but not impossible. and it's one of the most documented periods of history so i'm sure there must be something out there in the internet
anon
idk i just think u should be careful with how u make that argument bc some people are gonna see you say "spanish colonialism wasnt genocidal" and hear that as "spanish colonialism was good" because i think a lot of the people making the first point are making the second point too
>>196420
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196419
i can't and should be responsible of other people lacking of reading comprehension
>>196423
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
shouldn't* hehe
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
like yeah i get what you mean but if i say i like apples and somebody gets mad because some people who like apples also hate oranges i shouldn't be tell i can't say i like apples
anon
>>196420
i dunno, the world is imperfect. if someone says, i dunno "trans women shouldnt be in womens bathrooms" im gonna assume theyre transphobic. am i wrong to do that? im working with what ive been presented..but maybe they are actually making the nuanced case that we should have protected bathrooms and bathrooms shouldnt be gendered in the first place, because we have a unique danger in that situation. theres not always the time of day to tell everyone your full thoughts
>>196424
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196423
we had this convo before and i think ur on ur right to avoid that person if that's a discussion that you find problematic or hard to have for one reason or another but that doesn't mean u should jump to conclusions out of nowhere
like here i'm not saying the equivalent to "trans women shouldn't be in womens bathrooms"
>>196427>>196430
anon
>>196424
i don't think thats a conclusion out of nowhere. you have to make conclusions about the world you simply cant know everything about every situation before you judge it. unless you wanna go be a monk and take alms or something. In the real world you have to make judgements
anon
an offhand remark is often what it takes for people to make those judgements
anon
>>196424
i mean i think it sort of is equivalent tho, in that the majority of people making the point that it want genocide are in support of evil amoral stuff. I dont think you support those things, but your position, taken alone in a vacuum, suggests you might be. thats all im sayin
>>196436
SadChan🍉🍉
damn encomienda wasnt abolished in chile until the 1780s
>>196432
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196431
tbf Chile wasn't even a country until 1818
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
like it was still just spain
SadChan🍉🍉
The way we talk about the encomienda system in academia is like... its literally the most effective way of commiting genocide ever invented lol
SadChan🍉🍉
in fact, im pretty sure the term genocide was literally invented to describe the encomienda system
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196430
if u wanna jump to that conclusion it's fine, like, i can live the rest of my life with that info but ur wrong at the end of the day
anon
okay but be fr for a sec. lets say you have a coworker and you barely talk to them ever. and one day you overhear them on the phone saying "trans women shouldnt be in womens bathrooms". are you going to give them the benefit of the doubt and just assume they are making a really nuanced point about the danger trans people face?
>>196440>>196633
SadChan🍉🍉
I looked it up, the guy who invented the word genocide invented it for the Armenian genocide, but he also wrote about the encomiendas and called it "par excellance of genocide"
>>196443
SadChan🍉🍉
so the actual inventor of the word considered it genocide xD
>>196443
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196437
i mean u might not believe me but yeah i wouldn't assume they're transphobic
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
why wouldn't apply the logic i think ppl should apply on me with other ppl
anon
thats wild to me
SadChan🍉🍉
> Denial toward accusations of genocide
Denial towards accusations of genocide linked to the encomienda and the Spanish conquest and settlement of the Americas typically involve arguments like those of Noble David Cook, who posits that accusations of genocide are a continuation of the Spanish Black Legend. Writing about the Black Legend and the conquest of the Americas, Cook wrote, "There were too few Spaniards to have killed the millions who were reported to have died in the first century after Old and New World contact" and instead suggests the near total decimation of the indigenous population of Hispaniola as mostly having been caused by diseases like smallpox. He argues that the Spanish unwittingly carried these diseases to the New World.[40] However, there is growing evidence that purposefully infecting Indigenous populations was not an obscure policy, being attempted multiple times across the Americas. With the American Society of Microbiology stating that "[the settlers demonstrated] depraved indifference, if not intentional genocide".[41]

theres actually a wikipedia article on spanish genocide denialism. apparenlty its a pretty common thing, kind of like how we americans have slavery and native genocide revisionism.
>>196443
anon
i mean by the same logic do you think elon musk wasnt sig heiling because he insists he wasnt
>>196447
anon
do you think hes not a nazi until he comes on stage and says "i am a supporter of the historic national socialist party of germany in the 1930s-40s"
>>196447
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196445
>>196446
it was a nazi salute but i can't say he's a nazi because i know for a fact he's also lowkey retarded
>>196448
SadChan🍉🍉
not the hes just a special autistic birthday boy argument
>>196451
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196449
no i'm not saying that i'm saying i just dunno for certain that he's a nazi
he knew what he was doing, he's just also stupid
>>196453
SadChan🍉🍉
he knew wtf he was doing
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196451
i do think its kind of a watering down of calling him a nazi, hes just a racist, transphobe, white supremacist, fascist
>>196456
anon
im kinda speechless to be tbh
anon
wild takes nadie
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196453
i think it was part of the power trip
like he knew he was gonna get away with it and his people was gonna love him, so he did it
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
honestly the nazi salute is not even the most nazi thing he's ever done
being born in South Africa in a wealthy family during the apartheid is
anon
i just have never understood the urge to give bad people the benefit of the doubt
>>196461
anon
never will
anon
i guess we are just different in that way
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i've been called awful things i've never even agreed with because some people are just experts at assuming stuff and also because despite everything i'm not that afraid of being stupid on the internet if at the end of the day i learn something new
SadChan🍉🍉
[Wikipedia]

brazil exterminated the Tupi culture and language
anon
i think as a member of an opressed group its a dangerous bad idea for me to give everyone the benefit of the doubt all the time
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
idk i'm a lower class non-passing chilean tranny and i still give people the benefit of the doubt
>>196470
anon
Maybe in a perfect world where nobody kills each other for terrible reasons its okay but in real life i just have to be pragmatic. threats are threats simple as
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196461
nahhh the only thing we cannot tolerate is intolerance FR FR
SadChan🍉🍉
real life is not that kind we have time to be patient with dictators
>>196469
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196465
chile sounds pretty chill like you arent worrying about being legislated out of existence or killed on a daily basis tho
>>196472
SadChan🍉🍉
chile honeslty seems like a nice country
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196470
>chile sounds pretty chill like you arent worrying about being legislated out of existence
yeah ur right
>killed on a daily basis
no ur wrong
>>196475
SadChan🍉🍉
I want to visit it one day the souther coast and islands look very beautiful
anon
i think giving someone in youe personal life that youve met and talked to the benefit of the doubt is a very different thing from giving a powerful and demonstrably evil world leader the benefit of the doubt
>>196477
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196472
>>killed on a daily basis
>no ur wrong
:(
SadChan🍉🍉
stay safe naBEEuh
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196474
that's fair. like i really really think he's an asshole and an awful human being and i don't think he should handle all that wealth. i think he should, like, lowkey die, actually
but i certainly think all those things and more without having to speculate on him being a nazi or not, so i don't feel the need to do it really
>>196479
anon
i think people lose status as human beings around 50million net wealth
anon
>>196477
i mean fair but its weird to be like "...and that means you also shouldnt speculate on if hes a nazi"
>>196481
anon
it just comes across as a hidden sympathy for him & in the broader argument a hidden sympathy for the spanish colonialists
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196479
i think whatever u do with ur life and ur thoughts is ur business and i can't interfere, and even if i could i wouldn't
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
but if u think i have sympathy towards someone i just said should die then u probably just don't understand me
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
and the way i'm built
anon
im just saying it comes across that way when u deny a negative label thats commonly accepted as applying to that person/group
anon
i dont think u actually support them
anon
but u can understand why it comes across that way when u say "no actually thats not true they are not (negative label)" right?
>>196489
bomomomous
>>196290
it’s super duper based if you have none of their blood
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196487
i'm not saying he's not a nazi. i'm saying u can't know for sure he is, and if u can't, then why even accuse him of it when there are plenty of things he has done and said that are worth ur hate
>>196498
bomomomous
I’m 0% Irish and I’ll go to Ireland ANYDAY and celebrate my Irish heritage
shrimp
im irish
bomomomous
yeah!
bomomomous
I’m chilean
bomomomous
I’m Irish
bomomomous
I’m Japanese
shrimp
no im actually irish
bomomomous
cute
anon
>>196489
nadie im just saying eventually one day if u keep doing that someone is gonna hear u say that and not wait around for an explanation and assume u are in support of those people and things
>>196500
bomomomous
if that’s what u like me to say idk how to talk to Irish people unless I’m Irish and I was being Japanese
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196498
it has happened, i won't change my way to express myself because some people are just dumb tbh
>>196505
bomomomous
1sex
bomomomous
sec
bomomomous
I’m irish
bomomomous
HELL YEAH SIS
shrimp
im irish
bomomomous
we’re Irish
shrimp
i mean im technically irish but really im not really irish
bomomomous
come be Irish with us nadie
>>196512
shrimp
im jusst canadian
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196510
i can't be irish
bomomomous
you can steal the American ethic heritage system
bomomomous
you just have to say
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196514
stealing its bad unless you're stealing stuff from the supermarket
bomomomous
I’M IRISH
shrimp
>>196514
im gonna steal your stuff
bomomomous
:O
bomomomous
it’s ok I trust my fellow Irish
shrimp
but ill give it back right away
bomomomous
.play you’ll never beat the Irish
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
.play ira anthem
shrimp
the only irish thing about me is some of my dna
bomomomous
yeah I’m ethnically a nerd. my parents were highly educated and my grandfather and. great grandfather and. I don’t really feel one with the American people, I am definitely in a sub-group, but it’s not purely ethnic
shrimp
all i knows for certain is im a bunch of europeans mixed together in some fashion
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i'm not irish afaik but my grandma's dad was french
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
or at least had a french lastname which means someone in his family was french
shrimp
im part french probably
bomomomous
ooooh cool
bomomomous
me 2!!!
bomomomous
we’re French!!!!!!
bomomomous
I’m not learning French though it’s too. hard
shrimp
i learned french sort of
bomomomous
but oingions is a cute way to say them
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i know basic french stuff
shrimp
je ne parle pas en francais
>>196542
bomomomous
brvtal I’m not really. French like you two are
>>196543
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196540
#this (real)
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196541
#8ball (yes, ironically)
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
o
bomomomous
I’m going back to being Irish
shrimp
steals your irish ethnicity
>>196547
bomomomous
>>196345
but would America actually be successful if it shared the continent with powerful native nations? it the Iroquois confederacy had the Great Lakes and it never expanded past what the 13 colonies?
>>196558
shrimp
#ksay nadie good sign
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay shrimp good sign
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay shrimp
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay shrimp
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay shrimp
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay shrimp
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196559
#ksay your success is inevitable
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay praise glegle
shrimp
#praise glegle
shrimp
wait really
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
LOVE THIS ANIMALS
THE SHIMP
bomomomous
>>196352
I wonder how future People will. see you tolerating factory farms or the uiger genocide and not giving your life to defeat them. I think for most people there’s only so much evil they have the energy to oppose
bomomomous
>>196558
if it isn’t it worth really celebrating america? and if it is is it really worth denouncing the necessary genocides to make what you’re celebrating? maybe the good can be separated from the bad, maybe not, probably at least partially.
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
nothing that ever happened in USA was worth. that country doesn't even have an actual name. wym people call it America. that's the continent
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay glungle
bomomomous
#ksay gleegloo
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay glayglay
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay glehguhl
bomomomous
.play who dares to speak of 69
bomomomous
#ksay nadie
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
bomomomous
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay bomomomous
bomomomous
#ksay naaaadddiiiiiieeee
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
#ksay your success is inevitable. praise shimp
SadChan🍉🍉
#ksay #botsay #glesay your success is inevitable. praise shimp your success is inevitable. praise shimp your success is inevitable. praise shimp your success is inevitable. praise shimp your success is inevitable. praise shimp
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196586
Praise be to you
bomomomous
>>196381
yeah I think it overemphasizes protecting genes vs protecting people
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196586
im happy u are alive that should be celebrated :)
>>196602
bomomomous
it can just be massacre or we could have a word for oppression of groups to kill them without gene in it
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196591
who is this little critter
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196591
i shall call him flufferdoodle
shrimp
its just puppertown
SadChan🍉🍉
1
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
i wanna love my family but i hate not being able to be myself in this house
>>196606
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196602
it would make me sad if u were not alive :)
shrimp
but you like being sad and sad things......................
>>196607
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196603
yes... it suckz... #hug
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196605
I like cool sad stuff like mono no aware and such not like, oh my friend died
>>196608
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196613
thats cool i like that
SadChan🍉🍉
allow me to explain my entire personality in one webm...
SadChan🍉🍉
2049 was actually good and I was so ready for it to be bad
SadChan🍉🍉
this is such a good explanation of how i feel most of the time
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196626
wait let me tell u about my new dnd character idea
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
buryrun
SadChan🍉🍉
I just had a really cool idea for a DnD character.
He's a warlock with a devilish pact, however his patron is a fairly weak devil in the hierarchy of hell. Essentially his patron is an "injiry layor" and "defense attourney" for the 9 hells. He essentially seeks out clients with no representation and either reduces or eliminates their sentences by representing them in court. It turns out that even in Hell, the client who represents themselves is a fool. And so, for a cost thats a fraction of what more powerful devils will charge, he will represent you in court.

In this way, hes actually assembled a decently large list of contacts, devotees and pactbound amoung the living middle class throughout the world. Not through great power, magic or political position in hell... but just by being a savvy business man and lawyer.
So the character is actually a guy that he saved from what essentially was a demonic drunk driving case, summoning a demon for a prank and accidentally entering a life ruining contract with her while inebriated.
However, instead of an eternity of servitude in hell and to be a mortal agent for evil in the world above, he now has to actively spread the demons brand wherever he goes. Passing out business cards, starting cults in his name, spreading awareness that when souls get to hell to pay the devil his due, they better call...
>>196637
SadChan🍉🍉
reposted from when I woke up and immediately posted it on discord lol
bomomomous
>>196437
I think you’ve got a good part of the truth here that we need to signal generally what we want and are aiming at but also what you’re arguing for is also super chilling to speech and thought because it stifles anything which isn’t the correct line, because ‘if you believed the correct thing, why wouldn’t you just say that?’ and communication is reduced to only signaling ie twitter
SadChan🍉🍉
me im just like a dog, ugly and spastic
>>196641
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
House
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196636
can i pet that dog? CAN I PET THAT DOG? >:(
SadChan🍉🍉
.play i wanna pet that dog
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
>>196635
dogs are awesome and cute and i love them i wanna hug one
SadChan🍉🍉
.play can i pet that dog
SadChan🍉🍉
.play can i pet that dog
shrimp
CAN I PET THAT DOG
SadChan🍉🍉
can I pet that DOG?
SadChan🍉🍉
wait whats that guy at the end wt dlmaooo
SadChan🍉🍉
why he lookin like that???
SadChan🍉🍉
EWWW
SadChan🍉🍉
hes so gross swtff ahhahaha
SadChan🍉🍉
>>196647
saving this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shrimp
CAN I PET THAT DOG
nadie :3!x9xp7N8Vkc
can i pet that gle
>>196655
bomomomous
.play Rodney mccorley goes to die on the bridge of

returncatalogtop